In her book Alone Together, Sherry Turkle seems to be biased
against the advancement of the technological age. She attacks students
from MIT by calling them “cyborgs” because they are linked into the internet
almost all of the time, using disapproving rhetoric which causes readers to feel
bad because they can see themselves in these “cyborgs”. Turkle makes it apparent
to the readers that she frowns upon the use of cell phones and the internet,
yet Turkle freely admits to using them to the same extent as her daughter when
she writes “with a daughter studying abroad who expects to reach me when she
wants to reach me, I am grateful to be tethered to her through the Net. In
deference to a generation that sees my phone calls as constraining because they
take place in real time and are not suitable for multitasking, I text.” (Alone Together, 153) She
enables her daughter to call her, what mother wouldn’t? Yet she could easily
tell her daughter not to call as much or just not answer. Turkle seems hypocritical
in this book because she say one thing and then describes how she does the
exact opposite the next page over. Also, she continuously focuses on the
negative aspects of technology, instead of on the positives, like the fact
that, without such technology, she wouldn’t be able to instantly talk to her daughter and know what she's up to, like she can with the help of a text.
I agree with you saying she attacks students by calling them "cyborgs." It made me feel like she was being very demeaning in her argument.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with you; I think Turkle has a tendency throughout the book to condemn everyone else who frequently uses technology, but excuses herself when she does it, overly justifying her own use of it.
ReplyDeleteI'd push back a bit to say that though you all are calling it hypocrisy, I see it more that she is being honest about how she herself is part of the problem. She sees the appeal of being able to connect with her daughter, even as she sees the drawbacks on a reliance on technology. To me, this makes her seem actually more credible. But I understand your perspective.
ReplyDelete